Cover Change: Peaches

This is a bit old, but I stumbled across a cover change for Peaches by Jodi Lynn Anderson.

Here's the original:

This is an okay cover for me. The background color is nice and I like the repeated image of the peaches, but I'm not a huge fan of the font. Generally I like simplistic covers, but this one just isn't attention-grabbing enough and comes across as plain as opposed to striking.

Here's the new cover:

I like this new cover! The background image of the girl hugging the hug is cute and colorful, and the title text works well. My only complaint would be that it doesn't really properly convey the tone or the message of the story. This looks like a fun, light romantic comedy, which isn't quite in line with the book.

All in all, I prefer the new cover, though it isn't my favorite. Which one do you like better?