Rss Feed

Trickster's Girl: Review

Title: Trickster's Girl
Author: Hilari Bell
Release Date: January 2011
Published By: Houghton Mifflin
Genre: Fantasy
Pages: 288 pages
Goodreads Rating: 2.88 stars

Review: In 2098, there still isn't a cure for cancer, as Kelsa knows all too well. What she didn't know about was the boy who appeared the night she had to bury her father. A boy who claimed that the reason for the planet's slow dying isn't just human foibles, but magic. And only she can help. The problem is, will Kelsa even acknowledge the presence of magic, let alone go on the wild trip Raven suggests?

This book was a mix of a lot of things - adventure, fantasy, and dystopian - so I had some trouble classifying the genre. I went with fantasy because that seemed to be the biggest element. Often while reading this I felt like the futuristic setting was unnecessary. Its only purpose seemed to be to have a place with the environment is in trouble, but seeing as this is the case for our modern world too, I don't see any reason why the book couldn't be set in our times.

I also had a lot of trouble getting into TRICKSTER'S GIRL. Kelsa was difficult for me to relate to, although I can't pinpoint exactly why. The plot and writing simply didn't grab me hard enough. One thing I will say, though, was that the magical element of the book was interesting. I applaud the author for being different and using Native American mythology; I found that to be a fascinating and original aspect.

All in all, this wasn't really the book for me. However, others who enjoy paranormal books but want something different but not too different might like to take a look at this one, as it has a lot of elements similar to paranormals while still being unique. Adventure and magic are the two strongest parts, so this may not be the one to pick up if you're firmly a dystopian fan. I didn't enjoy TRICKSTER'S GIRL as much as I wanted to, but I hope anyone else who tries it does.

Shine: Review

Title: Shine
Author: Lauren Myracle
Release Date: May 2011
Published By: Amulet Books
Genre: Contemporary
Pages: 376 pages
Goodreads Rating: 4.14 stars

Review: Patrick is found dead, with wounds from a baseball bat, a fuel nozzle connected to a gas pump in his mouth, and the words "Suck this, faggot" written on his chest in blood, all because he's gay. His tiny home town, Black Creek, is disturbed but doesn't seem too interested in finding out who did it. But sixteen year old Cat, who had been childhood friends with him, is, and wants to make up for betraying him by solving his murder. As she investigates, what she learns isn't just about Patrick, but other people too... including herself.

One of the most striking aspects of this book is the setting. Although I live in a suburban town much larger than Black Creek, the small town Lauren Myracle paints feels honest. It's gritty, surrounded by poverty and drugs, but provides so much more depth to Cat's story. The intolerance and you're-either-in-or-out community portrayed is horrifying but scarily believable, given all the hate crime that goes on in the world, and Myracle shows this without ever becoming the slightest bit preachy.

Each character has his or her own heartbreaking story, but it never feels forced. Everyone suffers real problems, lending a great deal of emotional intensity to SHINE. I got an ache in my chest from reading this, and I appreciate that the author refused to shy away from such tough issues. The prose was unflinchingly honest and raw, digging deep into the heart of matters that other books might dance around.

The mystery wasn't an obvious one, even though SHINE was about not so much the mystery but the emotional journey accompanying it. I didn't see the answer coming until the very end, finding out at the same time as Cat. The ending was perfect for the story, wrapping things up well without presenting it in a pretty little package and a smiley face. Like the rest of the story, it struck me as true.

Though it's still early in the year, I can tell that this will make it onto my Best Books of 2011 list. I had my reservations going in because I didn't enjoy the author's previous books that much, but I was completely blown away by the intense, emotional ride SHINE provided. This is a book I recommend to everyone, because it's rare to find one with such a heavy story, and such beautiful prose brimming with honesty and strength. I will be reading more of this author's work.


FTC Disclosure: I received a free copy of this book for review. This is no way affected the review, which is 100% honest.

In-Class Essays (a.k.a the Bane of My Existence)

Crate-fuls of essays!
In general, I'm okay with essays. When my teachers aren't assigning them in crate-fuls (*cough cough* like they are now, since it's Hell Week), they can even be sort of fun to write. I like analyzing literature (not that I'm very good at it), and even those terrifying historical investigations are sometimes interesting. Still, a lot of work goes into essays, from the thinking to the outlining to the drafting to the revisions to the final, final, final edits. It takes a while to write them, like at least a few days if not a week.

Fifty-one minutes, however, is hardly sufficient.

Because yes, my lit teacher decided that he would give us an in-class essay that would be worth approximately 400% of our grade. When we walk in, he would give us a passage from the book we read (Black Boy by Richard Wright - fascinating book, by the way) and make us analyze it. In fifty-one minutes.

When I got the passage, it was my worst nightmare come true: there was nothing I could find to analyze. I spent five minutes sitting there in a growing pool of sweat, wracking my brain, before deciding that I would just come up with random junk and call it an analysis.

I scanned the passage. Frequent use of the word "I" and phrases like "the others", "the boys", and "white people"? Evidence of society-permeating racism isolating him! Saying "could not" five times? Evidence of society-permeating racism leaving him hopeless! Using short, choppy sentences? Evidence of society-permeating racism leaving him as flat and dreary as the sentence structure!

Yeah, I kind of just pulled all of that out of the air. Trying not to think about how horribly weak my arguments were, I moved on to the next part - drafting. I realized that with only about forty minutes left, I didn't exactly have time to both draft and revise and edit, so I decided to do the worst possible thing - combine all three processes.

I frantically wrote for a while, tearing through my pile of loose-leaf paper, and then doubled back and scribbled out half of what I'd written, replacing it with sentences that said more or less the same thing. Then I went on, reading and rereading the passage if I got stuck and trying to remember all those Deep Thoughts we came up with in class discussions.

I changed my thesis five times mid-essay. In the end, I'd crossed and re-crossed it out so many times that I had to squeeze it in the margins and use arrows. After the final thesis change, I still had to write about my main point and then do the conclusion.

I glanced at my watch. 2:15. Fifteen minutes? That was plenty of time! I would even have time to do a quick proofread at the end. A warm feeling spread throughout me as I thought about how I could possibly get a high enough grade to maintain my 96 average (got an 88 last trimester, hence my need for a 96 this one).

Then I realized that the class didn't end at 2:30. No, it ended at 2:20.

I surveyed the mess of papers surrounding me, swallowed, and began to write as fast as I could. My pen scratched the paper so hard that I made several tears, and my wrists and fingers began to ache like nobody's business. But my grade was on the line, so I kept spewing out words.

At last, with two minutes left, all I had left were a few sentences to finish up my conclusion.

Except I couldn't think of what to write. Not a single word came to mind. For 120 long seconds, I sat there, numb and getting numb-er. A series of images flashed through my mind: failing the essay, failing lit, failing high school, unable to get into a good college, forced to take to the streets, becoming a hobo, dying alone and hungry with a change-filled plastic cup....

With nothing to write, I picked up my hastily scribbled brainstorming from the beginning of class. And, right there:

Say [blah blah blah] at end of conclusion? 

There! My life was saved!

"Izzy? Class is over." I looked up to see my lit teacher and an empty classroom around me.

"Wait, I just have to write a few more sentences!"

"It's 2:25."

As he and I spoke, I ignored the cramps in my hand and scrawled the final words down. "Done," I said, with a sigh of relief, handing in my seven-page monstrosity.

But hey, at least I won't be a hobo.

XVI: Review

Title: XVI
Author: Julia Karr
Release Date: January 2011
Published By: Puffin/Speak
Genre: Dystopian
Pages: 325 pages
Goodreads Rating: 3.63 stars

Review: Nina lives in a world where girls are primed from a young age to be "sex-teens", and they must receive a government-issued tattoo of the letters XVI when they turn sixteen to let people know they're ready for sex. At fifteen, Nina is terrified of becoming a sex-teen. At least, until her mom suddenly dies after a horrifying attack and reveals to her shocking secrets that are even more terrifying. Everything she thought she knew about her past is shattered and now she must try to pick up the pieces to find herself again. Except things are never that easy, because her mom's killer is still out there. And he might be after her.

What I loved most about this book was the concept. In Nina's world, looking sexy and being flirtatious is put forward by the media as something that can get you anything you want, but is that so far from our own world? Even in such an enlightened age as ours, so many books and movies and TV shows display girls and women alike using their appearance as a tool for power and it's not too hard to imagine a world where this is taken to the extreme.

But although the concept was intriguing, I found the execution to be lacking in certain respects, such as the characters. Nina was a decently likeable character, and Wei was hands-down my favorite character (seriously, she was brimming with awesomeness). Sal was okay - I never really felt that he was particularly swoon-worthy but I didn't dislike him. The character that I did dislike, however, was Nina's best friend. Sandy was supposed to be an example of a sex-crazed teen girl, but even though I understood that, I wished that she had at least some depth to her and a bit more of a personality.

The author also makes frequent use of coined slang terms, like "emo-detector" and "trannies". Phrases like these can be clever and enjoyable if used in moderation, but I felt like they were just a bit too excessive and were sometimes confusing. It took me quite a while to figure out what FeLS meant, and every time I read "tranny", I couldn't help but think of the shorthand term for transgender people, which is a very different image from hovercars.

I still liked this book, but I wouldn't recommend it if you're picky with your dystopian novels as I am. The concept is fascinating, and most of the characters were well-developed and diverse, avoiding YA stereotypes. I did wish that Sandy was more interesting and that there were fewer made up terms, but other than that, this was an enjoyable read.